Life Settlements and the Key to Fair Market Value

One of the most important aspects of advancedhistory. Because of this, an occasional smoker can still
estate planning is the secondary market for lifebe looked at as a "non-smoker" risk and be offered
insurance. But, like any other financial planningmore affordable coverage.
strategy, it is not for everyone. The life settlementOnce the policy is in force, underwriting of the client
has traditionally been used an exit strategy foris never revisited. This approach to pricing life
unwanted or unneeded life insurance that mightinsurance policies serves the insurance carriers, but
ordinarily be lapsed or surrendered. Now lifedoes little for the consumer when the insured has a
settlements are being used with other strategies tochange in circumstances. In fact, it only reinforces the
provide estate liquidity using alternative fundingpower of the carriers. The ability to purchase a life
methods, such as premium financing.insurance policy back from an insured is limited to the
Trusted advisors have a fiduciary responsibility tocarrier that issued it in the first place. Their offer is
inform their clients of all of their options whenthe policy's cash-surrender value, which is based on
reviewing their estate plan. The fair market value ofmedical underwriting at the time of issue. Any change
life insurance should be at the foundation. Anyonein expected mortality that would increase the policy's
who ever bought or sold real estate knows thevalue can only be captured in the secondary market
importance of fair-market value. In recent years, ourwhen medical underwriting gets revisited, allowing for
access to real estate equity has kept our economya more accurate appraisal of the asset.
from screeching to a halt.A typical settlement application includes some very
Most of us probably breathe a sigh of relief everyimportant information, which is used for the appraisal.
time we get our tax statements in the mail and lookBasic questions concern the type of policy, the
at the assessed value. We know that the tax is ainsurance company, and when the policy was issued.
percentage of the assessed value from a countyThe insured signs a The Health Insurance Portability
appraiser and we are thankful that it's not based onand Accountability Act (HIPAA) form. Under HIPAA,
fair-market value. But, we would likely see the largestthe insured can share his or her medical history by
act of civil disobedience since the Boston Tea Party ifauthorizing a copy of their medical records to be
the county appraiser consulted the realtor everyreviewed. This is where the most accurate and
year. We would feel slighted, to say the least, if wetimely information concerning the insured's health
had to sell real estate for its assessed value insteadstatus is used to assess life expectancy. The third
of its fair market value. Our equity is based on apiece of critical information that is reviewed is a
more accurate appraisal, which takes into accountcurrent illustration of the life insurance policy. It will
supply and demand imbalances, among other things,show the estimated cost to carry the policy to
and leaves us with more opportunities.maturity. The non-binding offer can be given to the
Now, another widely owned asset offers the sameclient once these variables are known.
opportunity for a more accurate appraisal of fairIf the offer is accepted, the policy owner and
market value. The asset is life insurance. Thebeneficiary are changed to the institution making the
secondary market for life insurance is nothing new.offer, which assumes all premium obligations. The
Viatical settlements have existed in one form orinsured gets the settlement proceeds once the
another for years. They are usually associated withchanges have been recorded at the carrier. Any
investing capital in a fractional share of a policy inamount, up to the cost basis, is a tax-free
which the insured has a terminal illness. Generally, thereturn-of-premium. The amount above that, up to
insured has a life expectancy of fewer than 24the cash-surrender value, is taxed as ordinary income.
months and is pursuing a tax-free portion of theFinally, the amount above the cash-surrender value,
death benefit to fulfill an immediate need for cash.up to the settlement amount, is typically taxed as a
Life settlements involve the sale of a policy bylongterm gain since the policy must be at least two
someone over 65 who no longer needs, wants, oryears old. (This tax opinion was issued in 1997 by
can afford the policy. The life settlement is oftenKPMG Peat Marwick.)
used as an exit strategy for under-performingLife Settlements as Conventional Wisdom
universal or variable life policies in which "vanishingThe idea of using the secondary market to evaluate
premiums" have reappeared or the death benefit islife insurance is slowly becoming conventional wisdom
no longer guaranteed. These settlements arefor many reasons. Most important is that household
transacted on all types of individual and survivorshipnames, such as The Bank of New York, GE Capital,
policies including term policies. The settlementand Lloyd's of London, have committed billions of
amounts are always in excess of any cash-surrenderdollars to this market. This builds credibility for
value for the same reason that real estate is largelyregulators and the public as the perception shifts to
bought and sold for more than its assessed value.recognize life settlements as a sophisticated financial
Traditionally, before a life insurance policy is issued, anplanning technique. Many clients who are life
underwriter reviews the insured's medical records andsettlement candidates would probably never purchase
makes an offer to the insured based on acceptedinvestments without knowing all the facts and having
findings. Unless the case is declined, different offersa sound exit strategy. The time has come to
could be made including, preferred, preferred plus,determine the usefulness of life insurance, especially if
standard, table 2, and table 3, etc.the premiums have become a financial burden to the
Companies using the term "clinical underwriting" topolicy owner. The liquidity that the secondary market
assess mortality risks on an individual basis imply thatprovides can only enhance the value of life insurance
their underwriting is more accurate at the time ofby increasing demand in the primary market. Also, a
issue. This benefits consumers in the same waymore accurate appraisal of the asset is the key to
settlements do at the outset by taking a moreunlocking the hidden value for the benefit of the
individual approach to assessing an applicant's medicalconsumer.